Rudder bottom rib

I riveted the bottom rib together tonight. The rib is formed in two parts, one on each skin, and then riveted together. I started by riveting the aft-most 8 rivets on the right skin, For the aft-most two rivets, there is barely any clearance. Some builders use very thin bucking bars, but it’s easy to make a mess. Given my skill-level, I took the safe option and pop riveted the last two holes. These are counter-sunk pop rivets, and when the airplane gets painted, they will look just like the rest of the rivets.

Then I pop riveted the two parts of the rib together with 11 pop rivets:

These turned out to be a real pain, especially towards the aft end. I fabricated a “wedge tool” to act as a shim, allowing the rivet puller to angle away from the rivet, but still have the rivet head be flush with the surface. Several of the rivet shafts snapped off part way down the shaft, instead of flush with the rivet head. I trimmed them with side cutters, but it is frustrating to have it happen. I don’t know what I’m doing to cause the issue, I’ll have to do some research.

Then I clecoed the rudder horn brace, but didn’t have time to start riveting this tonight. It was a very tight squeeze, but I eventually coaxed it into position.

This afternoon I stopped by a fellow Chapter 338 member’s shop to check out his RV-9 build, and to borrow a 6 foot long bucking bar. It was a super helpful visit, and I picked up some good tips. The bucking bar is to back rivet the rudder trailing edge, once I finally get to that step, hopefully this weekend.

Riveted rudder spar to skins

I switched to my other hand pop rivet gun, and it produced better results. I installed the spar and top and bottom ribs, pop riveting the spar to the shear clips. Everything went well, and the results look good.

The next step is to rivet the bottom rib to the right skin and attach strip. Looking at the last two holes, it will be very challenging to get rivets in there. I think I’ll follow the advise of some other builders (and Vans), and pop rivet the back two holes. Once the aircraft is eventually painted, it won’t be noticeable.

Joined Rudder skins

With some help from Jen and Joyce, I was able to rivet together the left and right rudder skins tonight. The stiffeners on each skin are tied together with a single pop rivet, and the forward ends are pop riveted to the shear clips. There isn’t a great deal of clearance, so an assistant is needed to hold the skins apart while setting the rivets, from bottom to top. I had an annoying issue with the pop rivet tool where the mandrel was breaking off half way instead of flush with the rivet head, after fully forming the rivet. I had to trim off the mandrel on about half the rivets, which was a real pain. With the lack of clearance, I couldn’t get very flush with the rivet head, but it’s good enough given this will be completely enclosed. I’m going to need to figure out the issue, but it worked ok for tonight.

For the trailing edge, I picked up a tip from my EAA chapter and bought a couple of shelving channels for $5 from Home Depot. They are straight, narrow, and have holes cut that are an almost perfect match for 3/32 clecoes.

I taped the trailing edge, and clecoed one channel to each side of the trailing edge, giving a perfectly straight edge while the glue sets. Hopefully this will help the edge to stay straight while riveting.

Countersink trailing edge wedge

Tonight I counter-sunk the rudder trailing edge wedge. I used the Cleveland tool jig and counter sink, and was happy with the results.

Because of the shape of the wedge, and the fact that the hole is perpendicular to the wedge chord line while the counter sink is perpendicular to the face of the wedge, the holes ended up slightly oval looking, with a knife edge on the trailing edge side. From researching ahead of time, I think this is normal and not an issue. The wedge’s job is to hold the skins at the correct angle, while the rivets pass straight through with the heads gripping the skins, not the wedge.

Here are the completed rudder parts, ready for final assembly:

Over the last few days I did a couple of odd jobs, including dialing in the counter sink and practicing with wedge scrap.

I bought some side cutters and ground the face flat, then fixed the pop rivets with the broken mandrel.

I also made a start on the Horizontal Stabilizer by straightening out a couple of the doublers that were bent from the press.

Rudder shear clips

I finished back riveting the stiffeners to the left skin, then moved on to riveting the bottom rib to the right skin. With that done, I pop riveted the shear clips onto the left skin stiffeners.

Everything went well, except for a pop rivet where the shank broke off in the wrong place. I will need to pick up some side cutters and cut it off. Not sure why it broke there, perhaps I twisted or flexed the hand tool as I was giving it the final squeeze.

My countersink for the trailing edge wedge won’t arrive until Monday, so I’m blocked on the rudder now until that arrives and I can get that done. I started reading ahead on the Horizontal Stabilizer to see what I can get done over the weekend. Looks like plenty of deburring to keep me busy for a while.

I also looked at the timing for Vans to ship the next few kits. I need to make a decision in the next couple of weeks as to whether I want to go the quick-build route, or slow build. The slow-build kits have a 10 week lead time, and the quick build kits are 5-6 months. If going the quick build route, Vans recommend ordering the fuselage and wings together, or risk a longer delay. While I’m not in a hurry to finish, the idea of saving a year or more of work is certainly appealing. On the other hand, the idea of knowing every piece of the airplane, every rivet, bolt, nut, fitting, wiring run etc, is appealing.

Back riveted skins

After a little practice on some scrap aluminum, I back riveted the stiffeners onto the right rudder skin tonight. It was getting late by the time I finished, so I didn’t try to tackle the left skin. Riveting at midnight isn’t ideal with young kids sleeping in the house. It was a little slow at first as I measured each rivet with digital calipers to calibrate my technique. In the end I was moving quickly and getting a consistent head on each rivet. A couple of rivets ended up driven slightly more than I was aiming for, but are still within tolerance.

This was my setup, with a practice piece on the back riveting plate.

I started with this stiffener, and was happy with the results. I later increased the PSI from 20 to around 22, and the difference was noticeable; fewer hits needed to form the shop head. I’m using a 3x gun, which has a lot of power.

Here are all the stiffeners fastened to the skin:

I realized yesterday that I don’t have a #40 countersink that will work on the trailing edge wedge. Because the countersink is flush with the side of the wedge, but the hole isn’t (it’s perpendicular to the chord of the wedge), I need a countersink with a short and/or tapered pilot. I could probably grind one down, but I only have one. So I went ahead and ordered the special part from Cleveland tools. $20, and will arrive on Monday. That means I can’t finish the rudder until next week, but what’s the rush? I can always start on the Horizontal Stabilizer.

Dimpling rudder spar and stiffeners

I finished dimpling all of the rudder frame components tonight. It was a straightforward process, except for a couple of spots on the spar where the shop head interfered with the squeezer. If I had oriented the rivets so that the manufactured head was on the forward side, it wouldn’t have been an issue. At the time I set these rivets, I was thinking about putting the manufactured head on the side with the thickest material, but in hindsight I would have set these the other way around, since the shop head is a fraction of on inch too high to get the dimple dies to sit square to the hole. Not a big deal, I was able to use a hand tool to get a reasonable dimple on them.

Rudder skin deburring

Tonight I finished deburring the other rudder skin, and then took apart the rudder frame which was clecoed together. I made a mistake at one point, as I was deburring a hole in the skin with a counter sink in a hand tool, the tool slipped out of my hand and fell sideways while the countersink pilot was in the hole. This levered up and bent the skin, so I ended up with a bend up on one side of the hole and a bend down on the other. Luckily the skin didn’t crack, but it was very frustrating. Then I started the dimpling process by dimpling both of the skins. It was a long process, as I went slow and tried to avoid any scratches or mistakes. I started with the hole where I had bent the skin while deburring. As I hoped, putting a dimple in the hole straightened out all the damage, leaving no trace of an issue.

Next steps on the rudder will be:

– dimpling the stiffeners, ribs and spar – Monday

– counter sinking the trailing edge wedge – Tuesday

– back-riveting the stiffeners to the skins – Wednesday

– riveting the shear clips to the spar – Thursday

– pop riveting the skin stiffeners (with skins attached) to the shear clips – for this step I will need help; maybe Friday night

– riveting top and bottom ribs – Friday

– riveting the trailing edge – Saturday

– rolling the leading edges and pop riveting them together – Sunday

If all has gone well, it will be finished!

Rudder final drilling

I rigged up a better solution for my air hoses today, then final drilled the few holes that need it in the rudder. Most of the rudder parts are pre-punched to final size, and just need a little deburring. Then I debuted the skins, getting ready for dimpling, then assembly.

Here is what I ended up with for air hoses:

It’s much better with the hose coming down from the ceiling than to be dragging it around on the floor. The coiled hoses are very light weight, and are only rated to 120 PSI, which is well above anything I’ll be using them for.

I made up a little template to assist with the trailing edge drilling. The holes need to be drilled perpendicular to the chord line of the trailing edge wedge, which turns out to be 6 degrees forward of square with the skin. I found that the drill naturally hits that angle because the trailing edge wedge is already drilled to that angle, and the skins are so thin, it’s easy to get it pretty close. On a couple of holes the drill caught the upper (left) skin, and ended up enlarging the hole slightly. Once dimpled, will see if I need to do anything about it.

I final drilled all the holes in the top ribs, and matched drilled one on the front, but didn’t get a picture.

Then it was onto deburring, which is very carefully done given how thin the skins are. I made up a practice piece to see how excessive debuting affects the hole, after dimpling. It’s amazing how a few spins with the deburring tool remove enough material to really expand the hole diameter once dimpled. I got all of the left skin done, and partly through the left one, but I’m so tired I need to go to bed now. Will tackle some more tomorrow.

Rudder assembly

Tonight I clecoed together the rudder in preparation for final drilling the trailing edge and ribs (counterweight support and tip rib). It’s interesting how some parts are punched to final size, while others are not and require final drilling. At least all the stiffeners and corresponding skin holes are final size, that will save me drilling and debuting several hundred holes.

First I clecoed the ribs and stiffeners to the spar:

Then measured and cut the trailing edge wedge to length, and marked the skin where I’ll scuff with scotchbrite for extra adherence of the tape that will hold the wedge and the skin together while it’s riveted.

Then it was time to cleco the skins onto the frame. Here’s a picture of the whole structure clecoed together:

The next step will be to final drill the trailing edge holes in the skins and the trailing edge wedge. You can see the end of the wedge in the picture:

Drilling the trailing edge is tricky because the hole must be perpendicular to the chord line of the wedge, which means it intersects the skin at around 84 degrees instead of 90 degrees. Getting it wrong leads to a cascade of problems culminating in a wavy or curved trailing edge. I really want to get this step right the first time!